Categories: News

Court rejects EA’s First Amendment appeal in player likeness case

A court has ruled in favor of ex-NCAA athletes in a lawsuit filed against Electronic Arts and the NCAA which claims the companies used the student-athletes' likenesses in video games.

In a 2-1 decision, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals rejected EA's claim that the practice of using a player's likeness is protected by the First Amendment. According to the majority opinion, “EA’s use of the likenesses of college athletes like Samuel Keller in its video games is not, as a matter of law, protected by the First Amendment.”

The case, originally filed on May 5, 2009, was brought by former Arizona State University quarterback Sam Keller. In it, Keller and his attorneys claim that EA's NCAA games use the athletes' likenesses, accurately depicting the height, age, weight, and other information without permission.

“The Court of Appeals confirmed that EA’s defense – the First Amendment claim – was fundamentally and fatally flawed,” said Steve Berman, managing partner of Hagens Berman and the attorney who argued Keller's case on appeal. “We expect that when we appear before the trial court again this fall, the defendants will have a very difficult time mounting a new defense for their blatant exploitation of student-athletes.”

The ruling comes two weeks after the NCAA decided not to renew its licensing relationship with EA when it expires in 2014. Despite the NCAA's decision, EA maintains that it will continue to develop and publish college football games, a statement that was bolstered by the company's recent signing of a three-year contract with the Collegiate Licensing Company (CLC), the entity that handles trademark licensing and marketing services for universities.

Matt Liebl

Share
Published by
Matt Liebl
Tags: EA

Recent Posts

Review: Hitman 3 is the peak of the trilogy

To kick off 2021, we have a glorious return to one of the best franchises…

4 years ago

Hogwarts Legacy has been delayed to 2022

Last summer, we got our first official look at Hogwarts Legacy. The RPG set in…

4 years ago

EA to continue making Star Wars games after deal expires

Today, it was revealed that Ubisoft would be helming a brand-new Star Wars game. The…

4 years ago

PS5 Exclusive Returnal talks combat, Glorious Sci-Fi frenzy ensues

Housemarque shared lots of new details about their upcoming PS5 game Returnal. Today, we learn…

4 years ago

Lucasfilm Games confirms Open-World Star Wars handled by Ubisoft

Huge news concerning the future of Star Wars games just broke out. Newly revived Lucasfilm…

4 years ago

GTA 5 actors recreate iconic scene in real life

GTA 5 is probably the biggest game of all-time. It has sold over 135 million…

4 years ago